In the National Council, the wolf population ceiling was newly justified with forest damage. There is no evidence for this. According to the WSL, recreational hunters influence ungulates considerably more strongly during the hunting season than the wolf does.
Editorial Team Wild beim Wild — 5 October 2026
f FacebookX Twitter
Email
WhatsApp
Link
Save as a source! 

Symbolic image: heino eisner / Unsplash
In the National Council, it was claimed that the wolf damages the forest.
There is no general evidence for this. Research shows a picture that varies by location, and the WSL names a factor that influences ungulates more strongly during the hunting season than the wolf does: recreational hunting.
On 23 September 2026, the National Council approved Fabio Regazzi’s motion 25.4464 by 116 votes to 73. In future, wolves are to be released for killing as soon as a regional threshold is exceeded. During the debate, a new argument was added to the justification: damage to the forest. The experts who should know best contradict this sweeping claim.
The new forest argument
According to the «Bauernzeitung», committee spokesperson Monika Rüegger (SVP, OW) said: «Apparently, damage to nature, to young growth, has increased massively.» She did not cite a figure or a study. Environment Minister Albert Rösti referred to practice: «Ask the foresters and forest managers what needs to be done here.»
This is a remarkable turnaround. Until now, the dispute revolved around whether the wolf benefits the forest. Now it is supposed to harm it. The «Bauernzeitung» puts it aptly: suddenly the argument has been reversed.
No evidence for «more wolf, more browsing damage»
The «Bauernzeitung» made enquiries. Benno Schmid of Wald Schweiz says the association has no detailed figures on the wolf’s effect on forest regeneration. However, the position paper of the forest management association states that predators would «generally favour» forest regeneration.
David Clavadetscher, managing director of JagdSchweiz, also does not support Rüegger’s claim: “A general relationship of ‘more wolves = more/less forest damage’ cannot be assumed.” It is precisely the managing director of the umbrella association of recreational hunters who thereby pulls the rug out from under the wolf opponents’ forest argument.
The WSL study on browsing damage, which is frequently cited, examines the relationship with wildlife density. According to the «Bauernzeitung», it does not address the wolf at all.
More on this topic: Wolf threshold: National Council approves stockpiled kills, JagdSchweiz argues against itself
What the research shows
None of the studies evaluated here support the thesis that more wolves lead to more forest damage. Where an effect is measurable, it varies locally, depending on tree species and location.
- Białowieża, Poland: In the core area of a wolf pack, 50.5 percent of young trees were browsed, compared to 58.3 percent in the rest of the roaming area (Kuijper et al. 2013, Ecography). What was decisive was not the number of animals killed, but fear: red deer avoid places with high risk.
- Calanda, Grisons: In the territory of the first Swiss pack since 2011, researchers from the WSL environment found, according to Wild beim Wild, comparatively low browsing on silver fir, sycamore maple and rowan. Proof of a before-and-after effect is lacking, since there is no standardised browsing data from before the pack existed.
- Northern Poland: In forests with wolves, browsing is distributed differently. Beech trees were browsed less, while pines in plantations were browsed more (Wójcicki and Borowski 2023, Scientific Reports).
The WSL researchers Andrea Kupferschmid and Kurt Bollmann sum up the situation soberly: “The equation ‘wolf = less game = less browsing damage’ is, however, too simplistic and does not do justice to the complex interactions between predator, herbivore and vegetation” (waldwissen.net). This applies all the more to the reverse equation put forward in the National Council. No one in the debate has provided any evidence for it.
The studies do not rule out that wolf presence can locally lead to higher browsing damage. However, they refute the sweeping political claim that more wolves generally mean more forest damage. For forest regeneration, what matters is wildlife density, spatial distribution, tree species, forest structure and hunting pressure—not the number of wolves alone.
More on this topic: Dossier: Forest-Wildlife Conflict, No forest without the wolf: What predators mean for Switzerland, Hunting Fact Check
The strongest factor in the forest carries a rifle
The same WSL study contains a sentence that was missing from the Council debate: «In Switzerland, hunters are likely to have a considerably stronger direct and indirect influence on wild ungulates than wolves, at least during the hunting season.» This applies both to kills and to the spatial and temporal displacement of wildlife. According to the authors, Norwegian studies show that moose and roe deer primarily avoid encounters with humans because recreational hunting affects their population much more strongly than predators (waldwissen.net).
Anyone discussing browsing damage must therefore first discuss recreational hunting. The orders of magnitude show why.
