https://www.idahostatesman.com/opinion/readers-opinion/article317075978.html#storylink=cpy
Opinion By Nancy Lehman September 1, 2026 4:00 AM Gift Article Wildlife laws only work when they are followed, and most hunters follow them because they trust the system is fair and leadership is credible. That trust and credibility have been shaken because Idaho Fish and Game Commissioner Brody Harshbarger, who represents the Upper Snake Region, remains in his governor-appointed position while facing seven criminal charges for unlawful hunting activities. He pleaded “not guilty” to all charges, reportedly admitting to being the driver while his hunting partner indicated they were both shooting at elk. Commissioners are supposed to model the behavior expected of Idaho hunters. His case has yet to go to trial and has been repeatedly delayed with the next hearing scheduled for Sept. 23. The hunting incidents date back to December 2025. Regardless of the eventual outcome, Harshbarger cannot credibly fulfill his role going forward. Although he has voluntarily stepped back from his commission duties, he technically remains an appointed commissioner. His responsibilities include upholding Idaho’s wildlife laws, ensuring ethical practices and maintaining public trust in wildlife management. Commissioners should avoid conflicts of interest and uphold the integrity of their office. When a commissioner is charged with violating the very laws he oversees, it creates a clear conflict of interest and breach of public trust. This situation also harms conservation officers who must enforce laws while a commissioner accused of violating those same laws remains in authority. It creates morale issues among staff, public mistrust and perceived double standards. Idaho’s wildlife management system depends on ethical hunting, respect for regulations and confidence in leadership. Harshbarger’s continued appointment erodes all three. TOP VIDEOS Under Idaho law, Gov. Brad Little has full authority to remove commissioners at any time and for any reason. His continued inaction in this case is a choice — one that erodes public confidence in Idaho’s wildlife management system and leaves the citizens of the Upper Snake Region without representation. If Harshbarger is allowed to resume commission duties, he will be making decisions not just for his region but for all of Idaho. That should concern every Idahoan. The time is overdue for Little to remove Harshbarger and restore integrity to the IDFG Commission. Doing so would demonstrate accountability in wildlife governance, help rebuild public trust and strengthen IDFG’s credibility. Nancy Lehman is director of Concerned Citizens of the Clearwater Region based in Lewiston.
Read more at: https://www.idahostatesman.com/opinion/readers-opinion/article317075978.html#storylink=cpy